Customer Experience | CX Tips | Retail

How a Coffee Shop Had Me, Lost Me and Got Me Back Again: A lesson in Customer Centricity, Loyalty and the Importance of a Name.

Home » Customer Experience » How a Coffee Shop Had Me, Lost Me and Got Me Back Again: A lesson in Customer Centricity, Loyalty and the Importance of a Name.

As with the majority of Sydney workers, I start my day with a coffee. Most days, my cup and I appear in the line of my favourite shop. Here are a few lessons from one experience I’ve recently had:

#1 – Know what your customer wants, and let them know you know (Personalisation).

As I continued to grab my morning caffeine from the same place, I began to feel valued as a customer. The baristas know what I want, and they’ll deliver on it. Knowing your customers is vital to business. There are a hundred vendors who can supply the same thing as you can, but they don’t have the existing relationship your customers have with you. Knowing what they want not only makes it less effort for the customer to order but also leaves them with a sense of personalisation and positive perception. Both ease and happiness are cornerstones of good CX.

#2 – Delivering good customer experience raises expectation.

One day, things took a turn for the worse. As I came to the counter a newer employee was there to greet me.

“What will you be having today?”.

Stop right there. Don’t you know who I am? I’m here every day! My regular cap is why you exist.

“Regular Cap, thanks,” I say, as polite as possible.

“And what is your name sorry?”

“Gil” I respond…

“Great, thanks Kiel”.

Through a simple mistake, my perception of this business relationship completely changed. Now that the expectation of a particular personalized experience was set, not living up to that expectation was going to damage the experience. The same thing that was bringing me to this shop was going to be the one thing that gets me to leave. Ensure that when you set an expectation in CX, you are able to scale and continue to deliver on that expectation.

#3 – Negative emotion can lead to change in overall perception – Moment of truth

Shocked, I step aside and reconsider my loyalty to this cafe. If these guys don’t know who I am, why should I bother coming here? Arms crossed, I seem to notice the longer wait time in this place, the crowded and messy table top. And while we’re mentioning it, there’s not enough space to avoid people walking by. Why did I choose to come here? This might not be the spot for me…

Customers are human and not meeting expectations on one front can expose other small issues, ultimately their perception of the experience is what counts. One bad experience can be a moment of truth and can alter brand perception, creating a stigma around all touch-points with your business.

#4 – Getting feedback, Owning mistakes, closing the loop and communicating with customers is vital.

As I was frowning through my feelings of disappointment, I hear “Cap for Gil?”. The barista had identified the mistake and corrected instantly. Smiling, the barista motions towards the cup and says “Nice name today” and laughs. I realise he’s understood what’s happened and made an acknowledging joke about it. Hey… this guy gets me. What a nice guy. Reacting to customer feedback and auctioning to recover the experience can save you a customer, and many others.

Owning a mistake and understanding the immediate fix needed is crucial will keep loyalty and maybe even drive advocacy. It demonstrates the value of the customer and the relationship with the brand. There wasn’t a long-winded justification, or a policy and process with fixing the mistake. There wasn’t an endless amount of phone calls, forms to fill out and complaint lines to fill. Those who could fix the problem had the permission to fix it and did so promptly, customer centricity at its best.

So with cap in hand, I walked to work feeling fine about my local café. Hey – mistakes happen, human error is real and they weren’t shy about owning and fixing mistakes. I’m a reasonable guy, and my loyalty to their business was saved through a timely and appropriate response. Cheers, to the importance of Customer Experience!

Enjoy this post? Read more of our blogs here.
To request a demo of our product, click here.
To receive our Complete Guide to Successful Cx Programs, click here.

Run an AI-powered CX program beyond surveys

See our platform in action. A live demo tailored to your organization's needs.

Photo of author
About the Author

Resonate

Published on

Written by

Resonate

Upcoming Events

NEW RELEASE:
2025 Childcare & Retail Market Research Reports AUSTRALIA & UNITED KINGDOM

More Articles

View All

  • Blog

    How Reducing Friction in Customer Service Boosts Loyalty and Lowers Costs

    How Reducing Friction in Customer Service Boosts Loyalty and Lowers Costs

    By Alvier Marqueses • November 5, 2025
    High-effort service kills customer retention. Discover the simple three-step strategy to identify and remove friction points, leading to 20-30% higher loyalty and lower CX costs.
    Read More
  • Blog

    Deal Breakers Driving Customer Churn

    Deal Breakers Driving Customer Churn

    By Federico Sasse • October 30, 2025
    What makes customers leave? Discover the top 4 deal breakers driving customer churn, led by unresolved issues and poor staff competence. Learn how to fix your biggest service failures.
  • Blog

    The 4 Critical Signs You Need a New CX Platform Solution

    4 Critical Signs You Need a New CXM Platform Solution

    By Alvier Marqueses • October 28, 2025
    Is your old CX platform holding you back? Learn the 4 critical signs—data silos, stagnant metrics, late insights, and poor integration—that prove it's time to upgrade your customer experience management...

Resonate Resources

View All

    • Checklist

    Enhancing Citizen Experience: A Checklist for A Successful CX Program in LGAs | Checklist

    Explore key LGA CX strategies for enhanced citizen experience in local government areas, focusing on responsive service delivery.
    Read More
    • Guide
    Introduction to Launching Successful CX Programs

    Introduction to Launching Successful CX Programs | Guide

    Learn how NPS works and understand closed-loop feedback to elevate your CX strategy.
    • Guide
    Quick Guide to Level Up Your CX Program Banner

    Quick Guide to Level Up Your CX Program | Guide

    Discover industry-insider tactics for perfecting your CX Program in this quick guide that can help industries of all sizes.